> Advice Notes
  > Completion of the Core Indicator Pro-Forma for Best Value Road Condition Indicators
  > Condition Ranking
  > Consistency of TTS/SCANNER Results
  > DCD Accreditation Test
  > HMDIF Conversion Software
  > Loading TTS Data - FAQs
  > Misc. Documents
  > OF National Seminar 2004
  > OF National Seminar 2005
  > OF Newsletter
  > Pavement Condition Management Group
  > PCIS Newsletter
  > PCIS Regional Seminars 2009
  > Review of UKPMS Core Functionality
  > Roads Board Advisory Group
  > Roads Board Newsletter
  > SCANNER / TTS Treatment Rules
  > SCANNER Consistency Assessment
  > SCANNER HMDIF Specification
  > SCANNER QA Reports
  > SCANNER Research Reports
  > SCANNER Road Condition Indicator
  > SCANNER Specification 2005/6
  > SCANNER Specification 2006/7
  > SCANNER Specification 2007/8
  > Technical Notes
  > TTS Audit Reports
  > TTS Defects Index Preliminary Analysis
  > TTS Specification
  > UKPMS Annual Health Check 2009
  > UKPMS Health Check 2005
  > UKPMS Health Check 2006
  > UKPMS Health Check 2007
  > UKPMS Health Check 2008
  > UKPMS Rules and Parameters
  > UKPMS-Based BVPI Summary for 2004/05 and 2003/04 Surveys
  > Visual Surveys Best Practice






SCANNER Consistency Assessment

This report is from a project carried out by TRL on behalf of DfT to assess the consistency of SCANNER parameters and the RCI, and ultimately the effects of this on the consistency of the BVPI.  The aim is for Local Authorities to obtain a BVPI score for their network and know the confidence limits that can be put on this figure, thus giving them an indication of whether an increase in their BVPI score implies that the condition of their network has deteriorated, or whether it could be just a fluctuation due to machine consistency.

The most recent data available, from survey year 2006/7, has been used to calculate consistency values for the parameters used for the SCANNER RCI calculation and the RCI itself.  Data taken from the SCANNER Road Routes, surveyed by every machine during the SCANNER Accreditation tests, along with data from the Auditors’ and Contractor’s repeat surveys has been used for this assessment.  The method, devised by Chris Britton Consultancy within their work on SCANNER consistency, to calculate bias and random error has been utilised to calculate the consistency of the individual parameters and RCI for each 10m sub section length. In addition to this, a discussion of the effects of the consistency of the RCI on the BVPI has been included.

SCANNER Consistency Assessment Report - February 2008 08-02-28_PPR321 Assessment of the consistency of SCANNER parameters RCI and BVPI.pdf
Report from TRL on the consistency of SCANNER parameters and the RCI.  









Produced by Chris Britton Consultancy Ltd on behalf of the UKPMS Owners Forum